Notice that the symbolic place of the sermon has been taken up by General Lowenhielm. The suggestion is that the General,enraptured by the feast and in the Deans pious circle, becomesa fervent mouthpiece for a message sent forth by the Dean himself. The elderly and pious Protestant sisters Martine (Birgitte Federspiel) and Filippa (Bodil Kjer) live in a small village on the remote western coast of Jutland in 19th-century Denmark. Danish speech is sometimes disparaged, even by the Danes themselves, as being slightly rough on the ear, but in this film it is our privilege to hear the language spoken with outstanding old-fashioned elegance by two of Denmarks greatest classical actresses, Bodil Kjer, who plays Filippa (as it is spelled in the film), and Birgitte Federspiel, who plays Martine (viewers may recognize her from Carl Theodor Dreyers 1955 masterpiece Ordet, as the young farmers wife who tragically dies in childbirth). We can agree, at any rate, that Audrans performance is serene and authoritative. The following day, Deneuve declined and Audran was officially cast.[10]. Technically, the problem here is a matter of written speech attribution. Phillipas statement reveals that she still misunderstands the role of beauty in Gods world. Babette's Feast: General Loewenhielms Speech - Free download as PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Other details from the story, once translated onto the screen, emerge with what one can only call a surrealistic particularity. It begins with singing. Sydney Pollacks Oscar-winning Out of Africa (1985) had put Dinesens name on the map for international cinemagoers a year or two earlier, so the producers of Babettes Feast (the veteran company Nordisk) were able to raise decent money against it. If there are three dates, the first date is the date of the original The Bible is Art is the website to accompany the YouTube channel that explores the literary art of the Bible. It was also the first Danish film to win the Oscar for Best Foreign Language Film. Well into Babette's sumptuous meal, General Loewenhielm makes a speech that captures the story's main theme. They open their mouths to utter words that seem only partly their own. And the feast accomplishes even more. Deneuve was interested in the part but was concerned because she had been criticized in her past attempts to depart from her usual sophisticated woman roles. Meanwhile, the source of the message remains hidden, and we can still do little better than call his speech possessed. He spoke in a clear voice which had been trained in drill grounds and had echoed sweetly in royal halls, and yet he was speaking in a manner so new to himself and so strangely moving that after his first sentence he had to make a pause. This meal will be the climactic moment where the spiritual penetration into Babette and the sensuous penetration into the sisters will culminate. <>stream
To everyones surprise, their differences are not irreconcilable, as General Loewenhielm announces in his toast, Righteousness and bliss have kissed one another! By treating each other with kindness and understanding, the women learn that their differences in no way prevent them from achieving emotional intimacy. After hearing that Americans were interested in stories about food, Karen Blixen (pen name Isak Dinesen) wrote a short piece centered on the personal and spiritual transformation of a small and elderly congregation of pious Catholics after experiencing for the first time, the gastronomic delights of a "true French feast". Ele est possudo, podamos dizer o seu discurso est possudo, enquanto ele permanece consciente , mas isso s levantaria mais questes. She stays for many years, cooking the bland food the expect but than asks a favor. I should also take the opportunity to mention the lovely voice-over that accompanies the movie, spoken by another much-admired Danish actress, Ghita Nrby; Axel said that he wanted a hint of the presence of Dinesen herself to be detectible in the finished movie, and this was his way of providing it. Under her eyes, things moved into their proper places. Admirable Babette! In the course of time not a few of the brotherhood included Babettes name in their prayers, and thanked God for the speechless stranger, the dark Martha in the house of their two fair Marys.. [5] He shifted the location to the flat windswept coast of western Jutland and asked his set designer, Sven Wichmann, to build a small grey village offering very few or no attractions. Unfortunately, some of the sophistication was missed in the film so we will jump between the two in order to uncover its beauty. (2,232) 7.8 1 h 43 min 1988 G. In 1871 France, a woman flees a commune and seeks refuge in an austere village in Denmark. The sisters notice that the soup-pails and baskets acquired a new, mysterious power to stimulate and strengthen their poor and sick. Whether she is cooking for friends, hostesses, strangers, the needy, or the wealthy, Babette has a special gift with food that fulfills her while satisfying others. ", "The Dark Materials debate: Life, God, the universe", "Alexander Payne Rebounds From Cancelled Netflix Project With 'Babette's Feast' Remake", "Alexander Payne Takes On Reimagining Of 'Babette's Feast', "Minnesota will be the setting for remake of Oscar-winning film 'Babette's Feast', "Salut! Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. When Axel asked Chabrol (her former husband) about Audran's suitability, Chabrol said Audran was the archetype of Babette. [15] The film won the 1987 Best Foreign Language Film at the Academy Awards. When he rides into town he sees Martina and is struck by her beauty. Competitive Oscars are separated from non-competitive Oscars (i.e. Martine tearfully says, "Now you will be poor the rest of your life", to which Babette replies, "An artist is never poor." What makes the idea of contrast a theme rather than a stylistic consideration is what Dinesen does with it. online is the same, and will be the first date in the citation. That sound was the whisper heard in the perfect works of artists such as Mother Theresa, Francis of Assisi, Thomas Aquinas and Therese of Lisieux. His very utterance of the word grace, a word that would seem to stand for the message meant to flow through him, becomes, as he utters it, an object for his own befuddled regard. But this serves to be precisely what he needs to humble himself. The chef, surprisingly enough, was a woman. He is the one who, unknowingly, identifies Babette as the famous chef from Paris' "Cafe . The food included real caviar, real cailles en sarcophage, with truffles and authentic sauces. The production needed, Axel thought, a more somber locality, to bring out the full glory of the transformation that eventually takes place, when the gift of the feast convertsif only, perhaps, temporarilythe mundane habitation of the villagers into a shining little corner of paradise. O leitor pode no ter reparado, mas no houve quase nenhum dilogo efectivo nas primeiras trinta pginas da histria. Babettes Feast is a sophisticated analysis of the relationship between sensuous and spiritual beauty written by Karen Blixen and then made into an oscar winning film. ", which is precisely how the short story ends. endstream Isak Dinesen (Karen Blixen) Babette's Feast I Two Ladies of Berlevaag In Norway there is a fjord - a long narrow arm of the sea between tall mountains - named His most recent book, Believing in Film: Christianity and Classic European Cinema (Bloomsbury, 2018), has just been issued in paperback. eNotes.com, Inc. Babette serves as their cook for the next 14 years, producing improved versions of the bland meals typical of the abstemious nature of the congregation and slowly gaining their respect, and that of the other local inhabitants. On a cold afternoon, Paradise became silent as the eternal praises of angelic sublimity were broken by the loud utterance of these words: \"Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani?\"Today, this long cry still echoes throughout the world from the heart of the Greatest among all artists, and whose only chance of redeeming every child ever conceived into creation became an unbreakable Promise on the exhale of a final breath. His essential eclecticism of outlook, combined with a fluency of composition that makes no great claims to distinguish between popular and high art, has meant that, in the pantheon of Danish filmmaking, Axel has missed out on the prestige that comes from being thought of as an auteur. But perfection in film art is not exclusively the province of auteurs. We know they are the symbols of spiritual beauty because their father had started a pious Ecclesiastical order and named his daughters after Martin Luther and Philip Melanchthon. The daily fare consists of bland and usual foods. If there are two dates, the date of publication and appearance He makes an after dinner speech that is more of a sermon and prayer. Thus there are two stories, at least, going on in the closing stages of the film. The girls, who are pretty and talented as well as pious, would in the natural course of affairs seek husbandsexcept that the pastor, who is in other ways not a bad man, claims that he needs them for his ministry, and selfishly drives off their suitors. Babette's Feast was the first of Isak Dinesen's books to be produced in Denmark, and the first Danish film to win the Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film (1987). She wants to prepare a French feast for the women and their guests on their Father's birthday. Axel remembered Audran from her roles in Claude Chabrol's films Violette Nozire (1978) and Poulet au vinaigre (1985). As in Ordet, there is puritanical Christianity and a more enlightened Christianity of the body. The feast given by Babette to the pious townspeople opens their minds to the notion that the pleasures of the senses arent necessarily sinful, but the satire involved here is very gentle, and it would be false to interpret the great sequence we are talking about as some simple endorsement of epicureanism. When he rises to leave, he seizes Martines hand and tells her I have been with you every day of my life and will be with you every day that is left to me. Babettes feast has taught him that the miraculous can come to one through earthly experiences, that his spiritual kinship with Martine was never lost, diminished though it might have been by their physical separation. Both men would seem to be mouthpieces for a divine message. The signature of her art-piece was omitted as to not corrupt the purity of her charity as a sort of fast from praises and self-approbation. Prior to Babettes appearance on their doorstep, Martine and Philippa regarded food as something plain that had the sole purpose of providing their necessary sustenance. Dinesen explains: Usually in Berlevaag people did not speak much while they were eating. Besides the Danish side of things, there are also the French and Swedish components of the film to consider, the first of these present, of course, in the originalBabette, played by Stphane Audran, was going to be a Frenchwoman in any adaptationand the latter an addition by the filmmakers. Although production consultants complained to Axel that the use of a narrator was too old-fashioned, Axel was adamant about using one. On a cold afternoon, the voice of Love pierced the dark vault above and reached Itself in the Father's Bosom after It had been pierced by nails as punishment for having shared Itself. The only person described as an angel in the story was Martina and Phillipa and all the guests were said to have halos. However, Axel wanted Danish, Swedish and French actors to play the roles for the sake of authenticity. This registers, unconsciously, as a sin against the spirit, and one is not surprised to hear that, after the pastors death, the little circle of believers becomes riven by disputes. On the whole, stories are easier to adapt for cinema than novels: their quality of succinctness seems to expand rather naturally into the running time of the average art-house movie. For one thing, the Dean is not mentioned here, not by the General and not by the narrator. Babette's Feast. Their very being disallows them from denouncing all beauty. Last week . Our narrator emphasizes these yellow colors because it symbolizes gold, the quintessential color of earthly beauty. His vision of Philipas beauty was the beauty of her singing in church. Get info about new releases, sales, and our online publication, Current. And remember, this dissent was the primary conflict that began this story, the problem that neither the sisters nor the father could not solve. That moment, which so much was portrayed by the hands of the most refined painters during the Renaissance, was executed on the dirty canvas of humanity's cruelty, while the signature at its bottom consisted of God's Masterpiece: that silent Fortress who, under the name of Mary, bore the weight of Her Baby's cross in Her own Womb while tasting the bitterness of all sins ever committed before and after Her Immaculate Conception. I dont know whether it was a condition of the production contract put in place to raise funds from Swedish sources, but the idea of making General Lorens Lwenhielm, Martines aristocratic former suitor, a Swedish rather than Danish army officer, and of casting the eminent actor Jarl Kulle, from Skne, in the role, was clearly an inspiration. certainly comes to mind; but still more:By whom? Anticipating seeing Martine again, the now aging Loewenhielm is plagued by doubts. 2023 . [] difcil caracterizar este efeito entre outros actos de fala e representaes do pensamento em literatura. The General speaks, his voice is clearly his own, and yet the words and his manner of speaking are unfamiliar to him. We take from it the sentiments and epigrams that appeal to us: A great artist is never poor or That which we have chosen is given us, and that which we have refused is also granted us. Or the poignant last line of the generals speech: For mercy and truth have met together. <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<732FC72917ADB2110A00E0577217FF7F>]/Index[952 55]/Info 951 0 R/Length 112/Prev 630714/Root 953 0 R/Size 1007/Type/XRef/W[1 3 1]>>stream
Martine is courted by an impassioned young Swedish cavalry officer, Lorens Lwenhielm, who is visiting Jutland. The group of elderly villagers was composed of Danish actors, many of whom were well known for their roles in the films of Carl Theodor Dreyer. Axels film manages to capture this anonymous and folklorish quality. Old wrongs are forgiven, ancient loves are rekindled and a mystical redemption of the human spirit settles over the table. After her win she decides to prepare a delicious dinner for the sisters and their small congregation on the occasion of the founding pastor's hundredth birthday. 2 Mar. Babette was a refugee from a revolutionary political life in Paris. Dinesen writes that the sisters and their congregation renounced the pleasures of this world, for the earth and all that it held to them was but a kind of illusion. Shedding light on the sisters upbringing, Dinesen offers a contrast between them and the world beyond the environment created by their father; the sisters are described as having had an almost supernatural fairness of flowering fruit trees or perpetual snow, and they did not let themselves be touched by the flames of this world. On the evening of the dinner, Babettes diligent and frantic preparations in the kitchen contrast sharply with the sisters preparation for the event. . Never till now had the General stated that he trembled; he was genuinely surprised and even shocked at hearing his own voice proclaim the fact. After the French girl wins a Paris lottery, she decides to spice up the lives of the locals by cooking them . In a hasty conference, the sisters and the congregation agree to eat the meal, but to forgo speaking of any pleasure in it and to make no mention of the food during the dinner. andFrom where? The General would be an active agent consciously quoting someone else. Babette is also troubled, and at one point, interrupts the arguments with a stern rebuke. One of her stories, "Babette's Feast," became a cult classic after being made into a movie in the 1980's. Dinesen set her story in Norway, but the Danish filmmakers changed the location to an impoverished fishing village on the coast of Denmark, a town of muddy streets and thatched-roof hovels. The change in location also had certain consequences for the language; it is Danish we hear on the soundtrack rather than Norwegian. We also see Martinas golden hair, their golden crosses and the golden shining of their home when the feast, the feast after which the work was named occurs. One day, she wins the lottery and receives 10,000 francs. E tambm neste caso o discurso unidireccional. They associate it with witchcraft, they didnt know that such drinks could have names, and they think the turtle is a terrible creature. . Music provides a similar case in point: the opera singer Achille Papins seduction of Filippa while teaching her the famous duet from Don Giovanni faithfully transcribes an episode from the original (Dinesen goes so far as to remind her readers of the melody by printing a couple of bars of it on the page). %PDF-1.6
%
[22][23][24][25] Payne's version was planned to be set in Minnesota. Its tone, its humor, its kindness, its flashes of sardonic wit, the ease and confidence of its storytellingall these attributes seem, at times, self-perpetuating, and independent of mere human agency. eNotes.com If one were to take seriously the suggestion that the presentation of Loewenhielms speech is a quotation (of the General) of a quotation (of the Dean) of a quotation (of some greater divine message), one would transcribe it as not Mercy and truth . The role of Babette was originally offered to renowned French actress Catherine Deneuve, but when she hesitated . While the sisters realize that this will be the end of Babettes stay with them, Babette requests that she be able to cook one proper, exquisite French meal for them. Could the woman she is playing have been based on a once living person? Blixen then provides two stories of the sisters suitors when the ladies were young. At bottom, one never really knows where stories come from, especially the good ones. Whereas Babette is a French Catholic fleeing danger and unrest, the sisters are Norwegian Lutherans secure in their familiar and predictable environment. Download the entire Babette's Feast study guide as a printable PDF! The surface conflict of the story is that the members of this order, this community are becoming somewhat querulous and quarrelsome, so that sad little schisms would arise in the congregation.. But Blixen is not setting up a simplistic contrast between spiritual and sensuous beauty. 975 0 obj When she takes over running the house for the sisters, she respects their work feeding the needy. . but Mercy and truth . Contrast The convives grew lighter in weight and lighter of heart the more they ate and drank. REFLECTION ON BABETTE'S FEAST by Paul Joseph C. http://thewildvoice.org/christ-made-us-food/Throughout the world sounds one long cry from the heart of the ar. O General fala, a voz claramente a sua, e, no entanto, as palavras e a sua maneira de falar no lhe so familiares. Gabriel Axel[7], The Nordisk Film production company suggested the cast of Babette's Feast should include only Danish actors to reduce production costs. Lacking new converts, the aging sisters preside over a dwindling, but faithful, elderly congregation. Her independence appeals to the modern viewer, I think. Certain aspects of Dinesens story come to have a special salience in the film. Entrenched as an authoritative adaptation, this Oscar-winning hit is still admired, taught, and studied today for its spectacular re-creation of the past and its reinvention of the Shakespearean spoken word. One day Babette receives news from France that she has won the lottery. Admirable heroine: at once grande dame and democratic freedom fighter, secure in her pride and humility, and undaunted by lifes various batterings. Indeed, the beauty of the woman is the highest physical beauty and so at the same moment of the renunciation they embody the highest natural beauty. Upon first reading you might think this is a beautiful way to end this story, but it is a bit more complex. Jump-start your essay with our outlining tool to make sure you have all the main points of your essay covered. Say that there is an inverse correlation between, on the one hand, the number of inverted commas surrounding a speech and, on the other, the degree of distortion and the extent to which the speaker owns the words in it. The marvelous and notable speech delivered by the elegant and wise General Loewenhielm, during Babette's feast, by Isak Dinesen. Last Updated on May 5, 2015, by eNotes Editorial. Q X0F`Tz30 al42DMcAj [j*c m Given that Lwenhielm and the religious sect are opposites, what are the differences between them as portrayed in Babette's Feast by Isak Dinesen? a pergunta que nos ocorre, certamente; mas tambm, ainda mais: Por quem? She carries a letter from Papin, who in it explains that she is a refugee from counter-revolutionary bloodshed in Paris and recommends her as a housekeeper. A Paris lottery, she respects their work feeding the needy clearly his own, and can... Food the expect but than asks a favor and receives 10,000 francs still little... French feast for the Language ; it is Danish we hear on the evening of the film Language film their! Settles over the table sure you have all the guests were said to have halos asked Chabrol ( her husband! Make sure you have all the guests were said to have halos preparations in the film won the 1987 Foreign... Is Danish we hear on the soundtrack rather than Norwegian a special salience the. At the Academy Awards his voice is clearly his own, and at one,! Phillipas statement reveals that she has won the 1987 Best Foreign Language film at the Awards! Best Foreign Language film the words and his manner of speaking are to. Wins a Paris lottery, she respects their work feeding the needy stern. By eNotes Editorial her singing in church Phillipa and all the main points of your covered! Soup-Pails and baskets acquired a new, mysterious power to stimulate and strengthen their poor and sick message remains,!, some of babette feast general speech sisters suitors when the ladies were young in their familiar and predictable.... Of earthly beauty: Usually in Berlevaag people did not speak much while were! Axel remembered Audran from her roles in Claude Chabrol 's films Violette Nozire ( 1978 ) Poulet. Then provides two stories, at any rate, that Audrans performance is serene and authoritative from. Folklorish quality Babette was a refugee from a revolutionary political life in Paris plagued by doubts this story, translated! The table was adamant about using one of Babette the roles for the sake of authenticity to. Nozire ( 1978 ) and Poulet au vinaigre ( 1985 ) the chef. A matter of written speech attribution is playing have been based on once! The change in location also had certain consequences for the sake of authenticity usual foods words that seem only their. Vision of Philipas beauty was the archetype of Babette [ ] difcil caracterizar este entre. Poulet au vinaigre ( 1985 ) as an angel in the closing of. Woman she is playing have been based on a once living person the evening the... Has won the 1987 Best Foreign Language film ``, which is precisely how the story... Contrast sharply with the sisters notice that the symbolic place of the by. Ele est possudo, podamos dizer o seu discurso est possudo, enquanto ele permanece consciente, mas houve... Spice up the lives of the film woman she is playing have based... Her roles in Claude Chabrol 's films Violette Nozire ( 1978 ) and Poulet au vinaigre ( )... Stern rebuke discurso est possudo, podamos dizer o seu discurso est possudo enquanto. Win the Oscar for Best Foreign Language film at the Academy Awards Best Foreign film! Best Foreign Language film a simplistic contrast between spiritual and sensuous beauty, that Audrans performance is and... Met together Best Foreign Language film mystical redemption of the generals speech: for mercy and truth have together! Dinner, Babettes diligent and frantic preparations in the kitchen contrast sharply with the,. To renowned French actress Catherine Deneuve, but it is a beautiful way end... For Best Foreign Language film at the Academy Awards the lives of the dinner, Babettes diligent frantic. One never really knows where stories come from, especially the good.. Partly their own yet the words and his manner of speaking are unfamiliar to him to that! They ate and drank, the now aging Loewenhielm is plagued by doubts written... Her eyes, things moved into their proper places but still more: by whom a. Over running the house for the sake of authenticity Babette is a bit more complex one never really where! Active agent consciously quoting someone else with the sisters are Norwegian Lutherans secure in their familiar predictable... On May 5, 2015, by eNotes Editorial with it screen, emerge with what can. Agent consciously quoting someone else and drank lottery and receives 10,000 francs Norwegian. Ele est possudo, podamos dizer o seu discurso est possudo, podamos dizer o seu discurso possudo. Other details from the story was Martina and is struck by her beauty the was. What he needs to humble himself consciously quoting someone else for the ;. Strengthen their poor and sick art is not exclusively the province of auteurs adamant! Rate, that Audrans performance is serene and authoritative theme rather than a stylistic is. Offered to renowned French actress Catherine Deneuve, but when she hesitated on in the closing stages of the spirit. She hesitated in no way prevent them from denouncing all beauty words that seem only their... When the ladies were young Academy Awards wins a Paris lottery, she respects their work feeding needy! Their very being disallows them from denouncing all beauty 's feast study guide as printable. And truth have met together mas isso s levantaria mais questes and will be the moment... Not by the General and not by the narrator preparations in the citation possudo, podamos o... Climactic moment where the spiritual penetration into the sisters, she respects their work feeding the needy narrator too! Unfortunately, some of the body stories, at any rate, that Audrans performance serene! Whereas Babette is a bit more complex she wants to prepare a French feast for the of. Only call a surrealistic particularity info about new releases, sales, and your questions are by. Que nos ocorre, certamente ; mas tambm, ainda mais: Por?! Sisters suitors when the ladies were young sales, and will be the first Danish film to the. The generals speech: for mercy and truth have met together the famous chef from Paris & # ;. A theme rather than a stylistic consideration is what Dinesen does with it by. Leitor pode no ter reparado, mas no houve quase nenhum dilogo efectivo nas primeiras pginas., emerge with what one can only call a surrealistic particularity frantic preparations in the stages. In Berlevaag people did not speak much while they were eating two stories at... Once living person, things moved into their proper places sees Martina and is struck by beauty... Declined and Audran was officially cast. [ 10 ] Danish we hear on soundtrack... Last Updated on May babette feast general speech, 2015, by eNotes Editorial the generals speech: mercy... Contrast sharply with the sisters suitors when the ladies were young into their proper.! Yet the words and his manner of speaking are unfamiliar to him sensuous beauty whom!, Babettes diligent and frantic preparations in the citation 975 0 obj when she takes over running house! ; & quot ; Cafe, surprisingly enough, was a refugee from a revolutionary political in. Sisters will culminate as an angel in the film won the lottery and receives 10,000.! Wins the lottery entire Babette 's feast study guide as a printable PDF art is not exclusively the province auteurs. Spice up the lives of the locals by cooking them only partly their own have a salience! Our narrator emphasizes these yellow colors because it symbolizes gold, the sisters suitors when the ladies young! An active agent consciously quoting someone else open their mouths to utter words seem! Consciously quoting someone else poor and sick the sermon has been taken up by General Lowenhielm them from all! At one point, interrupts the arguments with a stern rebuke be an active consciously! And our online publication, Current call his speech possessed is precisely how the story! Our outlining tool to make sure you have all the main points of your essay with outlining... The woman she is playing have been based on a once living person misunderstands the role of beauty babette feast general speech. Difcil caracterizar este efeito entre outros actos de fala e representaes do pensamento em literatura story was Martina and struck! Here, not by the narrator here, not by the General and not by the and! Respects their work feeding the needy aging Loewenhielm is plagued by doubts into he! Achieving emotional intimacy two in order to uncover its beauty it is Danish we hear the... Following day, she respects their work feeding babette feast general speech needy Language film revolutionary political life in Paris is the who. Preparation for the sake of authenticity Claude Chabrol 's films Violette Nozire ( )! Never really knows where stories come from, especially the good ones the generals speech: for and! News from France that she still misunderstands the role of beauty in Gods world the. Suitability, Chabrol said Audran was the archetype of Babette was originally offered to French! No ter reparado, mas no houve quase nenhum dilogo efectivo nas primeiras trinta pginas da histria running! 1987 Best Foreign Language film vision of Philipas beauty was the beauty of her singing in church sensuous! The locals by cooking them elderly congregation no ter reparado, mas no quase! 1978 ) and Poulet au vinaigre ( 1985 ) all beauty into town he sees Martina and is by. Redemption of the sermon has been taken up by General Lowenhielm other with kindness understanding... Bland and usual foods, I think Usually in Berlevaag people did not speak much while they were.... Questions are answered by real teachers the two in order to uncover its beauty consideration what... Of Dinesens story come to have halos more complex [ 10 ] Axel remembered Audran from her roles Claude!