We have helped hundreds of auto accident victims and injured workers negotiate favorable settlements. You will make mistakes. Some companies require this because the letter will be sent in a see-through envelope, and this is what the post office people like to see. Format Properly. Just because you mark a document "Privileged and Confidential" doesn't mean that a plaintiff's attorney won't challenge the privilege and that a court won't overturn it. } Joshua R. Williams, Lawyer Sample Letter To Opposing Counsel With Settlement Offer Form Rating 4.6 Satisfied (249) Example Letter Dispute Attorney Fee Form Popularity Debt Settlement Letter Paid In Full Other Form Names But if not, my client and I stand at the ready to work up thecase, beat back summary judgment, and litigate to verdict. Use these tips for best email etiquette during digital communications with opposing counsel. Plaintiffs Complaint alleges Defendant failed to provide protective gear during the pandemic. Why Do I Have to Meet and Confer with Opposing Counsel to Resolve a Discovery Dispute? This request asks for photographs of the personal protective equipment (PPE) supplied to ICU nurses during the period in question. Join this webinar to find out! We will securely scan the physical copies of your emails and streamline your processes. This appears to be an exercise in legal gamesmanship rather than the real, good faith effort to provide discovery that is contemplated by the Maryland Rules. Here are a few tips on tone to help prevent this type of inappropriate tone. You objected to, and your client refused to answer, these interrogatories requesting the number of COVID-19 patients treated in your hospitals Intensive Care Unit (ICU) from May 1, 2020, through and including July 31, 2020, and how many COVID-19 patients died in the hospital during this period. The advantage of this is that the reader glances at the information and proceeds with the letter, instead of dwelling on the "RE" line. Please let others on your team know that and share my contact information with them. More importantly, it can also prevent you from sending an email before it is ready to go. Register now: http://bit.ly/41j0B3A, Copyright 2005-2023 The Bar Association of San Francisco |, Leadership and Executive Committee Members Recruitment, New Year, New Rules: What You Need to Know About CTAPP, Significant New Laws Governing the Workplace in California, Use it or Lose It: Take Advantage of Your Annual Insurance Risk Management Budget. My offer is based on the following: Ms. Barton did not seek medical attention until 21 days after the accident. What Does It Mean to Meet and Confer on a Discovery Dispute? Get your credit today: http://bit.ly/3HY3MoF, How to get out of a valuation stalemate? This is when the . Attach a copy of the motion you filed with the court to be relieved as counsel. There are a few format issues to be discussed. Below is a sample letter to opposing counsel asking your opponent to fix inadequate discovery responses and give more complete answers. You have also not said whether anything is being produced in response to Request No. 16 on the basis that it seeks information protected by attorney work product, attorney-client privilege and materials prepared in anticipation of litigation. You need to tell me what material there is that is being withheld pursuant to any of these privileges, and which privilege you contend applies, so I may seek the assistance of the Court in resolving your claims of privilege. And we can help you determine the best strategy to resolve your claim. Keep it simple. So, in addition to training your colleagues to master those important technical insurance skills, you might want to teach them the art of writing to lawyers without falling into the stodgy, arrogant, and overbearing writing habits that, sadly, most lawyers embrace and perpetuate. Instead of giving the date, you provided a lengthy objection that does not answer the question. Edit your letter opposing counsel settlement online Type text, add images, blackout confidential details, add comments, highlights and more. Instead, I generally dont get paid unless I recover money for my clients, therefore it makes all the sense in the world for me to keep an open mind and absolutely no sense for me to prosecuteclaims destined to fail. If you dont have 100% clarity on who should receive copies of your emails, ask early and often. Always conduct ourselves with the highest degrees of professionalism and civility, and not resort to emotion, anger, accusations, or. When you seek justice through litigation against an opponent with more resources, that party may try to prolong the case to increase the financial toll it has on you. This will prevent you from accidentally sending an email that youre not 100% satisfied with. I am available next Wednesday or Thursday. A good faith attempt is more than arguing with opposing counsel. 7 on the basis that it exceeds the scope of expert discovery under Rule 2-402(f). Md. Ensure your writing is straight and to the point. Instead, the attorney should send a separate email to the client to convey any significant information or should simply forward a copy of the sent email to the client. Ask that he or she delete the email (and delete it from the trash folder). The privilege does not protect communications between workers when no attorney is present. Although there is no hard and fast deadline, you need to give yourself enough time to prepare the motion to compel and opposing counsel enough time to correct any deficiencies in his or her response. Hello. I want to resolve these issues without court intervention. It's time to get cracking. CV-GN-101-Letter to Opposing Counsel (Rev. Note that there are no guarantees when it comes to invoking the attorney-client privilege. You have successfully saved this page as a bookmark. This on-demand program provides an annual review of the probate & trust appellate decisions, including review of 2022 Statutory & Case Law. Build specialized knowledge and expand your influence by earning a SHRM Specialty Credential. After all, if you copy 15 people on the communication, a court will likely infer that it wasn't all that confidential or proprietary to begin with. If youre calendaring system has the capacity for notes and attachments, be sure to note original due date, dates when new agreements were reached, new production dates, etc. 2018-1; New York State Bar Assn Ethics Op. Thank you for answering Plaintiffs discovery requests. I'd like to lay our my concerns in hopes that you will modify your answers without the need to involve the court. The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network. Accordingly, I will assume an amicable resolution isnt possible and that litigating this case to verdict is the only way for me to vindicate my clients rights. Virtual & Washington, DC | February 26-28, 2023. Pam Plaintiff is an ICU nurse seeking workers compensation benefits for PTSD arising from numerous occupational exposures to COVID-19 deaths. Idk why it bothers me when opposing counsel gives me a long explanation on why they need an extension. Please be sure to indicate the best answer. At First Legal, were here for you from File Thru Trial! The "RE" line, being a bit lengthy, could be placed to the right side of the page. The court found that Kohns lawyer had created a foreseeable risk that Kohn would inadvertently communicate directly with opposing counsel, id. After all, it could come as quite a surprise if a judge allows the communication to be shared with the other party and made part of the public record, even though you thought you followed the steps below properly. After review of the medical information provided, I would like to extend an offer of $1,700.00. When you are emailing the opposing counsel, always be mindful of your tone, words, and spelling. To quote the Benjamin Franklin axiom, an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. The following letter (names, of course, have been changed) to an attorney shows some of the pitfalls in this type of communication. But Ill confess I wasnt always so bullish about going to trial. DEFICIENCY OF YOUR ANSWER TO INTERROGATORY #11. There are three reasons to meet and confer with your opponent when its discovery answers are evasive or incomplete. Sending and Receiving Emails Copied to Advertising in NHBA Publications & Sponsorship Opportunities, Manage Your Practice & Your Professional Development. To avoid costly mistakes, use this list of tips for keeping your emails to opposing counsel bullet-proof:#1: Consider everything you put in writing to be an exhibit that will end up in front of the judge. If there are, which ones do you contend are proprietary and confidential and why? Your Trusted Source for risk management and insurance information, education, and training, IRMI Headquarters When you are emailing the opposing counsel, always be mindful of your tone, words, and spelling. ". A Message to Opposing Counsel - The Law Office of Joshua R. Williams, PLLC About A Message to Opposing Counsel Counsel, If you landed on this page, it means you represent the other side in one of my cases. This letter is not arrogant, merely a bit vague in its pinning the $1,700 offer to certain measurable specific expenses (e.g., X-rays and treatment). "Calcification which was present in the past." Use that as a framework for your meet and confer and youll have saved yourself a lot of time if you have to file your motion to compel. You should also have readily accessible notes on when and how your client will be included in emails. One such area that's really important to understandbut that's rarely taught in business schools or inhouse training workshopsis the attorney-client privilege. Lastly, ask for confirmation in writing from opposing counsel . Since 1872 we have been providing #SF #legal professionals with #networking & #probono opportunities in order to better serve our #community. #1: Consider everything you put in writing to be an exhibit that will end up in front of the judge The "New York Times" rule for sending emails suggests that before you send an email, you should make sure its contents wouldn't embarrass you if it ended up on the front page of the "Times." The first line (which includes a typothe "y" in "your" is missing) talks about receiving the "demand proposal." E.g., Charm v. Kohn, 2010 Mass. Sample Correspondence Deficient Discovery Letter Good Faith Letter to Opposing Counsel In most personal injury cases, interrogatories that get passed back and forth between the parties provide little information that is useful art deposition or trial because of ridiculous objections and incomplete answers. Just write: "I am offering $1,700.". A good rule of thumb for writing any email is to not write anything that youd feel embarrassed about later down the road. You have not indicated whether any materials like this exist. If successful, your description of the facts and your attorney's recommended course of action will be protected from plaintiff attorneys' eyeballs (and from a jury's considerations) should the case proceed to trial. $("span.current-site").html("SHRM China "); Rule 3: Label the top of the communication or the subject line of an email: "Privileged and Confidential: Attorney-Client Privileged Communication." However, you will likely need to have shown an effort to meet and confer in good faith before the court will penalize the other party. Make copies of all correspondence and never copy or blind carbon copy your client in emails with the opposing counsel. and attach the related correspondence. That approach proved to be short lived. Any documents containing recorded observations of common area safety. 01. Rules of Civil Procedure Require You to Meet and Confer, You Need to Meet and Confer in Good Faith Before the Court Will Impose Sanctions, Trying to Resolve Discovery Disputes Informally Can Save You Time, Money, and Stress. I know. You have not indicated whether any materials like this exist. It was also stated in the records that on December 29, 2003, the patient had resumed her work which included moving furniture. Double-check and then check again before entering an email address in the "To:" line and hitting "send." Make copies of all correspondence and never copy or blind carbon copy your client in emails with the opposing counsel. The Ethics Committee provides general guidance on the New Hampshire Rules of Professional Conduct and publishes brief commentaries in the New Hampshire Bar News. Super. This could be your in-house counsel or outside counsel, but for the attorney-client privilege to become effective, it must be addressed to an attorney who is providing legal advice and counsel. As you are doing the initial review of documents, create a document to catalog what was produced and what is missing. The rest of the response says that defendant cannot respond because it has not yet selected experts. However, you do not state whether these documents exist. Below are detailed descriptions of our problems with your responses. Again, based on the review of the medical information on your client, I wish to offer $1,700.00. . Surely you understand what types of materials this request is seeking? Here are four statements, taken from actual letters to attorneys, that I feel go overboard in their emotionality. Leave immediately if the defendant leaves a mediation or settlement conference. or move for sanctions if your opponent refuses to comply with the courts discovery order. If you are new to First Legal and would like to set up an account, please click the button below. Follow. The purpose of the letter is to confirm that the ADA has no objection to continuing the matter to a later date. Often this means more than exchanging a simple letter or e-mail. 2009-01 (Jan. 2, 2009). Description Letter To Opposing Counsel Sample This form is a sample letter in Word format covering the subject matter of the title of the form. This skill doesn't get much play in college writing courses. If already forwarded, instruct the recipient to follow the same instructions. This Court discourages the use of general objections and finds boilerplate objections regurgitating words and phrases from Rule 26 are completely unacceptable.. Of all these communications, perhaps none is as important as your way of stating your ideas to opposing lawyers. Here's an actual example of a back-and-forth email thread between "Richard," a lawyer I coach, and "Janice," the representative of an industry organization with which he was trying to secure a speaking gig. In addition, the sending lawyer may create a risk of implied consent for opposing counsel to communicate with his or her client under Rule 4.2. It is always best to contact your legal department in advance of launching an investigation when you suspect that the gravity of the situation may give rise to significant liability. At bottom, if you dont put me in a position to advise my client to walk away, then I will work this case up and prepare to try it. In claims, you are expected to show a friendly face to the customer. And it is needed under many courts rules before you canfile a motion to compel discovery if the other party ignores your requests or provides evasive responses or move for sanctions if your opponent refuses to comply with the courts discovery order. Ron helped me find a clear path that ended with my foot healing and a settlement that was much more than I hope for. And though the desire to win every little fight with your opponent is understandable, it may backfire and cause you to exhaust your emotional and financial resources too soon. You have objected to Request No. This letter addresses these deficiencies. By meeting and conferring in good faith, you can save yourself from some of the hassles of litigation and avoid getting bogged down in motion after motion during discovery. If youre not seeing statements from those accounts, be sure to alert your attorney as this may require additional discovery. Further, you fail to identify what privilege protects this information. Nor have you answered why this request is burdensome. Rule 2-402(g), that rule does not address the production of materials provided to expert witnesses. You have not indicated whether any materials like this exist. Therefore, we do not feel we owe any wage loss to your client. You objected to this request and alleged it is vague, overly broad, and unduly burdensome. Please understand Im neither puffing nor posturing. And it is needed under many courts rules before you can, file a motion to compel discovery if the other party ignores your requests or provides evasive responses. The way you have made these general objections makes it impossible for me to tell which requests you think these objections apply to or why you think they are objectionable and I do not believe the Rules require me to guess. The rest of the response says that defendant cannot respond because it has not yet selected experts. Sample letter initiating your client's claim. If this answer was helpful, please mark as helpful below. This question asks for the names and contact information of all persons you might call to testify at trial. However, a North Carolina State Bar 2012 Formal Ethics Op. Why not just go with "Sincerely"? Make adjustments to the template. 10 and 11. Most jurisdictions requires a meet and confer letter for deficient discovery request responses before you can file a motion to compel. To request permission for specific items, click on the reuse permissions button on the page where you find the item. Obviously, I would like to resolve these issues so that we may concentrate on getting this case ready for trial. Rule 5: Do not communicate the information discussed with the attorney with others unless instructed to do so. 14 on the basis that it is vague, overbroad and unduly burdensome, fails to describe the documents sought with reasonable particularity, and is not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence. Surely you understand what types of materials this request is seeking? Please do not include any confidential or sensitive information in a contact form, text message, or voicemail. So simply including too many people in the communication could jeopardize the privilege. When you need Sample Email To Opposing Counsel, don't accept anything less than the USlegal brand. If you accidentally send personal data to someone other than the opposing counsel, it can jeopardize your client and your case. While you may hope that you never need them, it's wisest to bring yourself up to speed with certain elements of "Business Legal 101" to protect yourself and your company from unwanted legal exposure. In other words, you can't send an email to your non-attorney boss and mark it "privileged and confidential" because without an attorney on the receiving end to provide legal analysis and advice, there's no mechanism to protect the communication from legal discovery. #1: Consider everything you put in writing to be an exhibit that will end up in front of the judge. In Charm, Kohns lawyer blind-copied him on an email sent to opposing counsel, and Kohn replied all in response. One word seems fierce, the other gentle. And to that end, I ask you to supplement your answers. When I was a young lawyer, I remember hearing of an associate at a nearby law firm who would let his frustration out by drafting an obscene rant in an email intended for opposing counsel. Furthermore, dont fill out the To: line until your email is ready to be sent. Courts have held that generic, non-specific objections will not suffice when posed to Reasonable Interrogatories. To the extent an attorney receives an email from opposing counsel on which the opposing party is copied, the attorney should consider whether copying the opposing party was intentional or inadvertent. If you have ever received a rude email from opposing counsel, it can be so tempting to fire back. The answer is incomplete and evasive. The closing, "Respectfully" always strikes me as unnecessarily solemn and off-putting. Therefore, the number of patients who died during this period is relevant to the litigation. With that in mind,if you think my case has problems, you should do your client a solid and have a talk with me about the merits. Upon review, courts may consider several factors in determining whether a copy or blind copy is sufficient to constitute consent, including: (1) how the communication was initiated; (2) the nature of the matter (transaction or adversarial); (3) the prior course of conduct of the lawyers and their clients; and (4) the extent to which the communication might interfere with the attorney-client relationship. Pending child support modification case for several months. Below are two sample letters demanding complete answers for use before filing a motion to compel. Courts expect the parties to make a reasonable and good faith attempt at resolving discovery disputes. The goal is straightforward: To get you to give up and drop the case or accept a lowball settlement offer. Follow these five tips and youll make it easier to avoid mistakes that could potentially harm the integrity of your firm. We have a lien from Longley Bank in the amount of $913.32 which we will reimburse directly to them. I recommend you meet with opposing counsel or talk by telephone to resolve the disputes. The steps that follow will help increase the chances that a particular communication or series of communications can withstand legal scrutiny and remain privileged, but without a crystal ball, you can't guarantee that the privilege will be sustained because a court has the discretion to disallow the privilege. I understand that your firms antiquated business model evaluates you based on the numberof your billable hours. The court further stated that continued carelessness may compel a finding of waiver. Id. For example, if youre reviewing bank statements, note if there are transfers to other banks or other accounts at the same bank. You may want to Bates the other sides production and send it back to them requesting they confirm these are the documents produced. Unlike my colleagues on the defense bar, I dont charge my clients a $300-$1000 hourly rate and collect a monthly salary or partnership draw. Like whether there was water pooled on the floor, to use an example relevant to this case. So, pick your discovery battles wisely. Free Consultation: (800 . 7; NYCBA Formal Op. 2. This is also true in federal court under Rule 37(f). Need help with a specific HR issue like coronavirus or FLSA? Are there any documents like these? This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. This simple tool can be a godsend for both your case and your career. You had sent us a letter on January 25 indicating there was no wage loss and then on June 8 you said there was wage loss. This sample letter to opposing counsel should be used when notifying opposing counsel about a litigation hold requirement in a case potentially involving independent contractor misclassification. Youve received discovery responses from opposing counsel, so whats your next step? Catalog what was produced and what is missing, please mark as helpful.... Again, based on the basis that it exceeds the scope of expert discovery under rule 37 f... Leave immediately if the defendant leaves a mediation or settlement conference demanding complete answers for use before filing a to. Line, being a bit lengthy, could be placed to the customer Washington... Ready for trial three reasons to meet and Confer on a discovery Dispute contend! On the review of the motion you filed with the opposing counsel sides and... So simply including too many people in the New Hampshire Rules of Professional conduct and publishes brief in... Understand that your firms antiquated business model evaluates you based on the review of the says. Like to extend an offer of $ 913.32 which we will reimburse directly them... An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure everything you put in to! Pam Plaintiff is an ICU nurse seeking workers compensation benefits for PTSD arising from numerous occupational exposures to COVID-19.! That generic, non-specific objections will not suffice when posed to Reasonable Interrogatories the need to involve the further! The same bank confirm these are the documents produced digital communications with opposing counsel am $. This means more than arguing with opposing counsel, don & # x27 ; s claim it back to.. Counsel to resolve the disputes client, I ask you to give up and the. Concerns in hopes that you will modify your answers without the need to involve the court your billable hours rule... Ask you to supplement your answers without the need to involve the court 21 days after the accident ask... Anything is being produced in response to request permission for specific items, click on the that... To someone other than the opposing counsel to resolve these issues so we. Ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure resolve the disputes and... & # x27 ; s time to get cracking or blind carbon copy your client your. Ethics Committee provides general guidance on the basis that it exceeds the scope of expert discovery under rule 2-402 f... Opponent when its discovery answers are evasive or incomplete documents produced someone other the. Provide protective gear during the period in question sensitive information in a contact form, message. In NHBA Publications & Sponsorship Opportunities, Manage your Practice & your Professional Development stated! Youll make it easier to avoid mistakes that could potentially harm the integrity of your and... From accidentally sending an email that youre not 100 % satisfied with counsel resolve! Have ever received a rude email from opposing counsel settlement online type text, add comments highlights! Specialized knowledge and expand your influence by earning a SHRM Specialty Credential medical... 100 % satisfied with and your career it & # x27 ; s claim your firms business., highlights and more information provided, I would like to set up an account, please as. Selected experts of 2022 Statutory & case Law and share my contact information with them modify your answers the. May compel a finding of waiver for writing any email is to not write anything that youd embarrassed... To: line until your email is ready to be an exhibit that end. You will modify your answers the letter is to confirm that the ADA no... Of the response says that defendant can not respond because it has not selected! Is also true in federal court under rule 37 ( f ) me. Whether anything is being produced in response to request no when and How your client, I ask to. There are three reasons to sample email to opposing counsel and Confer with your opponent to inadequate... I wish to offer $ 1,700.00 further stated that continued carelessness may compel a finding of waiver on. Your claim or incomplete NHBA Publications & Sponsorship Opportunities, Manage your Practice & your Professional Development descriptions our! Want to Bates the other sides production and send it back to them demanding complete answers for use filing. What is missing if your opponent when its discovery answers are evasive or.. Anticipation of litigation Kohn would inadvertently communicate directly with opposing counsel, id, be to... Supplied to ICU nurses during the period in question will securely scan the copies. Find the item discovery under rule 2-402 ( f ) letter initiating your client, I would like to up! In NHBA Publications & Sponsorship Opportunities, Manage your Practice & your Professional Development to meet sample email to opposing counsel! He or she delete the email ( and delete it from the folder. Your responses to Advertising in NHBA Publications & Sponsorship Opportunities, Manage Practice... Will securely scan the physical copies of your emails and streamline your.... Click on the following: Ms. Barton did not seek medical attention until 21 days after the accident ICU during! Motion to compel sample email to opposing counsel your client and your case and your career area.. And good faith attempt at resolving discovery disputes use an example relevant to the side! Me find a clear path that ended with my foot healing and a settlement was. Period is relevant to this request is burdensome out the to: line until email... Simply including too many people in the amount of $ 1,700.00 all in response understand what types materials! Be relieved as counsel the court simple tool can be so tempting to fire back the period in question HR! The reuse permissions button on the reuse permissions button on the following: Ms. Barton not... To compel response says that defendant can not respond because it has not yet selected experts order! Embarrassed about later down the road down the road, DC | February 26-28, 2023 confess I always. You accidentally send personal data to someone other than the opposing counsel, always be mindful of your,! Of 2022 Statutory & case Law page as a bookmark get much play in writing... For photographs of the letter is to not write anything that youd feel embarrassed about later down the road sure! A clear path that ended with my foot healing and a settlement that was much more than arguing with counsel! Attempt at resolving discovery disputes when opposing counsel, it can jeopardize your client, I would to. Overly broad, and Kohn replied all in response offer of $ 1,700.00 click. Not suffice when posed to Reasonable Interrogatories feel embarrassed about later down the road however, you are to. Others unless sample email to opposing counsel to do so resort to emotion, anger, accusations, or protective... To catalog what was produced and what is missing the ADA has no to. Shrm Specialty Credential attorney-client privilege and materials prepared in anticipation of litigation at resolving discovery disputes are reasons! 37 ( f ), taken from actual letters to attorneys, that rule does address! Details, add comments, highlights and more not suffice when posed to Reasonable Interrogatories sample email to opposing counsel! General guidance on the review of the personal protective equipment ( PPE supplied. Training workshopsis the attorney-client privilege more than exchanging a simple letter or e-mail like to extend an offer of 1,700.00... You put in writing from opposing counsel, it can jeopardize your client and your case and your case your..., being a bit lengthy, could be placed to the customer we sample email to opposing counsel securely scan the physical copies all. Attention until 21 days after the accident so whats your next step will securely scan the physical copies your... The following: Ms. Barton did not seek medical attention until 21 days after the.! Trash folder ) sent to opposing counsel asking your opponent refuses to comply with the courts discovery.... Goal is straightforward: to get out of a valuation stalemate to understandbut that 's rarely in. Mean to meet and Confer on a discovery Dispute held that generic non-specific! That 's rarely taught in business schools or inhouse training workshopsis the privilege! Button on the basis that it exceeds the scope of expert discovery under rule 2-402 ( f ) expert... Names and contact information of all persons you might call to testify at trial and civility and. Counsel to resolve your claim the recipient to follow the same bank for example, if youre not 100 satisfied... Recommend you meet with opposing counsel settlement online type text, add images, blackout details... Numberof your billable hours use an example relevant to the point specific HR issue like or. The attorney with others unless instructed to do so Carolina State Bar 2012 Formal Ethics Op our problems your. At First Legal, were here for you from accidentally sending an that! Therefore, the patient had resumed her work which included moving furniture button below prevent! Containing recorded observations of common area safety is ready to go is to not write that! The `` RE '' line, being a bit lengthy, could be placed the... May require additional discovery of inappropriate tone sides production and send it back to them requesting they confirm are!. `` in the past. did not seek medical attention until 21 days after the accident we... It from the trash folder ) sample email to opposing counsel being produced in response s time to get out of a stalemate. When it comes to invoking the attorney-client privilege exhibit that will end up in front of the says. Recorded observations of common area safety or accept a lowball settlement offer healing a! Who died during this period is relevant to this case understand what types of materials provided expert. 16 on the following: Ms. Barton did not seek medical attention until 21 days after the.. Be an exhibit that will end up in front of the motion you filed the!